Reconciling deconsumption with the market economy : different approaches[Essay] by Lauren Haddon, Ronan de Pins, Jordane Lagneaux, Yann Auger, Vaïté Leprince-Ringuet

2009-04-28

The authors were part of the “Alternative Management” third year program in HEC in 2008/2009

This selection of five essays is an indicative tribute to the opening aspirations of the Alternative Management Major Class of 2008/9. The five works, each distinct and different, exemplifies and reflects the subjective, individual responsiveness of the authors to the challenge set in the title of the essay.  “Déconsommation can appear as an incongruent ideal in the framework of mainstream free-market.” Using some material you have gleaned from the course, articulate a reaction to this contention and suggest plausibly and critically how less might become a consumer commodity in the market context. In the first essay, Lauren Haddon offers a comparative analysis between a modernist and post-modern vision of consumption in order to find an approach that allows integrating deconsumption within the market economy. Then, Ronan de Pins envisages adopting deconsumption as the market economy's new ideal, focusing on the role of corporate social responsibility. Jordane Lagneaux proposes making “less” a consumer commodity and to modify our relation to consumer commodities in general. Yann Auger suggests that the concept of deconsumption is not new in economics, and that this theme will be adopted by the free market for financial as well as economic reasons. Finally, Vaïté Leprince-Ringuet evokes the potential roles that “morality” and “ideals” can play in the economy, using this as a starting point for reconciliation between the practice of the market and the theory of deconsumption.

David Bevan

Quote article  Lauren Haddon, Ronan de Pins, Jordane Lagneaux, Yann Auger, Vaïté Leprince-Ringuet, « Reconciling deconsumption with the market economy : different approaches », 28 april 2009, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Essay]
http://appli6.hec.fr/amo/Articles/Entry/Item/82.sls

In the same section

Barefooted Bankers - by Jean-Michel Servet

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Céline Lévy

Jean-Michel Servet aims at presenting a critical analysis of microfinance that underlines its limits and depicts its promises. After defining the term, the author explores the context and roots of its development and growth. He illustrates the diversity of the models of microfinance organizations...

>>Read more

The History of Development – From Western Origins to Global Faith - by Gilbert Rist

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Camille Deniau

For decades, development has been used as a political tool, to justify economic and social policies. It made people believe in global well-being and in the elimination of poverty. Why then is development today at the centre of a passionate debate, if it has failed so greatly? It is definitely...

>>Read more

On Ethics and Economics - by Amartya Sen

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Vaïté Leprince-Ringuet

The modern theoreticians of economics have put forward its scientific nature in order to avoid ethical questioning. However its nature is dual: mechanical and ethical. To reduce individual behavior to rationality and egoism is fundamentally inaccurate, and greatly impedes the power of economics....

>>Read more

The big tipping point The social question at global scale - by J-M Severino et O. Ray

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Marie Baranger

Jean-Michel Severino and Olivier Ray release a comprehensive analysis of the new global arrangement. Through new changemakers’ and anonymous – though representative of the new economic and social order –  stakeholders’ portraits, the authors highlight the characteristics of the...

>>Read more

La Maison Nucingen - by Honoré de Balzac

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Raphaël Saillant

La Maison Nucingen is the story of the Baron de Nuncingen’s wealth, and its techniques for self-enrichment at the expense of the derelicting aristocracy. In this novel, the old aristocracy of the Ancien Régime and the Restauration are sinking, while the capitalist bourgeoisie, to which belongs...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Essay

What's the economic impact of the... This research paper presents the... by Victor Cabanes, Hélène Doutriaux, Anne Hurand
The development: a radical criticism of... Who and what does the development refer... by Pablo Nomanza
The French AMAPs: a partnership between... This past decade has seen the emergence... by Maëlle Gasc
Center for the promotion of ecological... How to conciliate private housing in... by Camille Portejoie
Altai Consulting Altai Consulting started its operation... by Domitille de la Morinerie
Protecting biodiversity, satisfying the... In the current context, biodiversity,... by Frédéric Benhaim
Meaning in work: in what sense does a... This document is the synthesis of an... by Yann Auger, Sarah de Barthès, Yann Devaux, Vaïté Leprince-Ringuet
Auroville Auroville was founded in 1968 by “The... by Aurélie Gillon
Habitat et Humanisme Created in 1985 in Lyon by a real... by Fleur d'Harcourt
Limits and stakes of local democracy.... What is local democracy? What is its... by Anne Hurand