From theory to reality: how liberalism tends to materialize its assumption of universal egoism of man[Essay] by Yann Auger

2009-08-02

The author was part of the “Alternative Management” third year program in HEC in 2008/2009

Noticing that men are unable to agree on a mutual conception of morale and life, liberalism advocates for a society which does not lean on moral conceptions, that is to say an amoral society. Based on individual free determination, this system relegates morale in the private sphere. Managing society according to this principle leads to rely on the impersonal mechanisms of abstract law and free market. Markets should orientate private interests toward common interest thanks to the “invisible hand” analyzed by Adam Smith and help to pacify society (Montesquieu). To work on a large scale, such a society needs people to accept to pursue their own interests and to free themselves from what prevents them to act rationally: their behaviours should be utilitarist. But utilitarist maximization is only a facet of human behaviour, as authors such as Marcel Mauss and George Orwell show: some behaviours can be disinterested without being charity though. Those behaviours go against the homo oeconomicus utilitarist fiction, the modern figure of utilitarism which is raised as the norm by the system. They are jeopardized by the extension of liberalism. Behind the repeating claims “for mentalities to change” (the “necessary” rehabilitation of profit is a good example), stands out an essential struggle for our future: the attempt to merchandize everything through free market economy enhances rational selfishness. Thus, liberalism leads to deny a fundamental part of humanity: the spirit of gift, such as analyzed by Marcel Mauss. How to get over it? By education in particular and a come back to simple values such as the “common decency” described by George Orwell.

Quote article  Yann Auger, « From theory to reality: how liberalism tends to materialize its assumption of universal egoism of man », 02 august 2009, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Essay]
http://appli6.hec.fr/amo/Articles/Entry/Item/89.sls

In the same section

The “Terre de Liens” property company

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Laura Loffler

The Foncière Terre de Liens property company is a solidarity-based investment tool which collects savings from citizens to purchase land in order to install or maintain solidarity-based agri-rural project sponsors. Legally, it is a partnership limited by shares and it is managed by the Cooperative...

>>Read more

Industry and Cooperation - by Jacques De Heere

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Jacques de Heere

After having introduced the Acome group in its historical, economical and political dimensions, Jacque De Heere presents us his career in the French industry : today, he works with passion at the top of the hierarchy of Acome, since he is the chairman and CEO of this group. Finally, Jacques De...

>>Read more

Developing a critic conscience for managers - by Philippe de Woot

[Proceedings]

[Proceedings] : Philippe de Woot

Directors and Managers must be aware of the advantages and drawbacks of the capitalist system nowadays. As Philippe de Woot states in his report, this awareness leads to further thought about the implementation of an alternative management that places the humane dimension in the center of the...

>>Read more

The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism - by Max Weber

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Alice de Rochechouart

This book studies how the protestant ethic and its asceticism contributed to shape and to spread the spirit of modern capitalism. The reformed Protestants believed in predestination, and were looking for the evidence of their divine election in strict labor ethics, where economical profit was...

>>Read more

The Shale Gas Mirage - by Thomas Porcher

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Elsa Walwer

At the heart of the shale gas debate, Thomas Porcher delivers a study about the consequences of French shale gas reserves exploitation, from an economical perspective. Stemming from the French legal and economic specificities, he exposes and dismantles the arguments put forward by pro-shale gas...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Essay

Center for the promotion of ecological... How to conciliate private housing in... by Camille Portejoie
Limits and stakes of local democracy.... What is local democracy? What is its... by Anne Hurand
Ecological Footprint and sustainable... Over the past few years, a responsible... by Claire Nativel
The Jai Bhim Network in Hungary The paper presents the activity of the... by Csilla Narai
Protecting biodiversity, satisfying the... In the current context, biodiversity,... by Frédéric Benhaim
SELCO, solar energy to fight poverty SELCO India is a social business... by Margaux Vinez
The role of the State in micro-finance... Over the last 25 years, the... by Olympe Bédier
Eco villages: from utopia to real... Eco-village projects have been... by Thomas Lebreuil
Waste management in France, current... At a moment where prices of raw... by Nathalie Rusé
The community of the free : Hackers,... This essay represents a personal view... by Claudia Pöpperl