From theory to reality: how liberalism tends to materialize its assumption of universal egoism of man[Essay] by Yann Auger

2009-08-02

The author was part of the “Alternative Management” third year program in HEC in 2008/2009

Noticing that men are unable to agree on a mutual conception of morale and life, liberalism advocates for a society which does not lean on moral conceptions, that is to say an amoral society. Based on individual free determination, this system relegates morale in the private sphere. Managing society according to this principle leads to rely on the impersonal mechanisms of abstract law and free market. Markets should orientate private interests toward common interest thanks to the “invisible hand” analyzed by Adam Smith and help to pacify society (Montesquieu). To work on a large scale, such a society needs people to accept to pursue their own interests and to free themselves from what prevents them to act rationally: their behaviours should be utilitarist. But utilitarist maximization is only a facet of human behaviour, as authors such as Marcel Mauss and George Orwell show: some behaviours can be disinterested without being charity though. Those behaviours go against the homo oeconomicus utilitarist fiction, the modern figure of utilitarism which is raised as the norm by the system. They are jeopardized by the extension of liberalism. Behind the repeating claims “for mentalities to change” (the “necessary” rehabilitation of profit is a good example), stands out an essential struggle for our future: the attempt to merchandize everything through free market economy enhances rational selfishness. Thus, liberalism leads to deny a fundamental part of humanity: the spirit of gift, such as analyzed by Marcel Mauss. How to get over it? By education in particular and a come back to simple values such as the “common decency” described by George Orwell.

Quote article  Yann Auger, « From theory to reality: how liberalism tends to materialize its assumption of universal egoism of man », 02 august 2009, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Essay]
http://appli6.hec.fr/amo/Articles/Entry/Item/89.sls

In the same section

La Maison Nucingen - by Honoré de Balzac

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Raphaël Saillant

La Maison Nucingen is the story of the Baron de Nuncingen’s wealth, and its techniques for self-enrichment at the expense of the derelicting aristocracy. In this novel, the old aristocracy of the Ancien Régime and the Restauration are sinking, while the capitalist bourgeoisie, to which belongs...

>>Read more

Impact of the diverse visions of social entrepreneurship on resources-organizations practice

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Camille Portejoie

The dynamic of social entrepreneurship is getting stronger in Europe. The number of organizations, which dedicate themselves to social entrepreneurship support is growing. At the same time, researchers strive to find an unanimous definition of the concept and their works emphasize the many...

>>Read more

Translucent society – taking to an end the myth of a benevolent state

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Badis Boussouar

Translucent society focuses mostly on the French model of government and tries to understand how the state, through its interactions with companies and people, makes the society. It is thus in understanding better the role of human beings in this mechanism that one can make it work in a less...

>>Read more

Is Capitalism self-destructive? - by Patrick Artus

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Florent Gitiaux

This paper is not a faithful summary of the subject text. It highlights the key technologies described in the book, which enable us to go further than description. Current forms of capitalism encompass no vision of evolution which itself risks the future of capitalism. The paper suggests that these...

>>Read more

Is Capitalism moral? - by André Comte-Sponville

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Violaine Laurens-Berge

Is Capitalism moral? is a synthesis of several lectures delivered by André Comte-Sponville about business ethics. His first goal is to clarify the concept of relations between economics, politics and ethics in a context where the trend of Corporate Social Responsibility might lead to confusion on...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Essay

Reconciling deconsumption with the... This selection of five essays is an... by Lauren Haddon, Ronan de Pins, Jordane Lagneaux, Yann Auger, Vaïté Leprince-Ringuet
Wikipédia : individual contribution... Wikipédia is one of those huge... by Guillaume Tellez
Waste management in France, current... At a moment where prices of raw... by Nathalie Rusé
SELCO, solar energy to fight poverty SELCO India is a social business... by Margaux Vinez
The community of the free : Hackers,... This essay represents a personal view... by Claudia Pöpperl
Is car-sharing the next way to drive in... The concept of car-sharing has been... by Rudy Guénaire
Auroville Auroville was founded in 1968 by “The... by Aurélie Gillon
Ecological Footprint and sustainable... Over the past few years, a responsible... by Claire Nativel
What's the economic impact of the... This research paper presents the... by Victor Cabanes, Hélène Doutriaux, Anne Hurand
Altai Consulting Altai Consulting started its operation... by Domitille de la Morinerie