Identity and Violence: The illusion of Destiny - by Amartya Sen[Reading report] by Margaux Vinez


The author was part of the “Alternative Management” third year program in HEC in 2011. Margaux Vinez also studied at the Paris School of Economics, in the Master for Public Policies and Development. After having worked in China, Nepal and Morocco, she is currently in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where she estimates, for the World Bank, the consequences of an agricultural policy upon a tropical forest. She should soon begin a Ph.D. thesis that will be about adaptation policies to climatic changes in developing countries

Amartya Sen, who is an Indian economist and philosopher, wrote this book from a series of conferences he gave at the Boston University. In Identity and Violence, Sen criticizes the advocates, as well as many of the opponents, of the theory of a clash of civilizations. He reminds us of the dangers and irrelevance of reducing one's own identity to a religious dimension, and refutes the validity of any reasoning based on the identification of distinct civilization blocks. Last but not least, he defends for everybody a right to cultural freedom.

Quote article  Margaux Vinez, « Identity and Violence: The illusion of Destiny - by Amartya Sen », 02 december 2012, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Reading report]

In the same section

The Birth of Biopolitics - Lectures at the Collège de France 1978-1979 - by Michel Foucault

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Marie Calmettes

In these Lectures at the Collège de France (1978-1979), Foucault traces back the main stages in the art of governing, which has been transformed in the Westernized world since the 18th century. He analyzes the rise of liberalism and neo-liberalism, respectively in the 18th and 20th century....

>>Read more

Conditions for the sustainability of cultural brownfields – Study of the functioning of the Brussels Art Factory

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Marianne Rauche

A cultural brownfield can be defined as an industrial brownfield, most of the time, which is converted into a place where different types of art activities are created, produced and diffused. Since 1970, along with deindustrialization, a lot of cultural initiatives have been lead with an...

>>Read more

The Free Software Foundation.


[Essay] : Raphaël Saillant

The Free Software Foundation supports the free software against the proprietary software, so that anyone can have a free access not only to the software, but also to its code, to its fabrication recipe, to be able to change it anytime.

>>Read more

Fab Labs


[Scenario] : Julien Bicrel

Fab Labs are small workshops equiped with machine tools allowing personal fabrication and prototyping of a variety of objects. The first Fab Lab was created within the (Massachussets Institute of Technology) MIT in the early 2000s and today, Fab Labs are part of a world network. The promise of...

>>Read more

Risk generation: how ans why protest movements evolve and renew themselves?

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Pierre-Antoine Chiarelli

This thesis considers the Risk Generation movement, which was founded to contest changes to  internship  training schemes. Despite the scarcity of its resources, this movement was a real success. This paper is focused more on the reasons which explain the constitution of the movements and those...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Reading report

Why and How we should abandon nuclear... Should we abandon nuclear power ?... by Ingrid Colonna
Mass Destruction – The Geopolitics of... Every 5 seconds, a child aged of less... by Sophie Rauch
Human development – Struggle against... Health and education are priorities in... by Nastassja Kern
Eco-capitalism, sustainability model... In this economic essay, Patrick... by Aurélie Gillon
Profit over people - by Noam Chomsky In this book, Chomsky denounces... by Julie Vinay
Governing the Commons – The Evolution... Governing the commons, which was... by François Bottollier-Depois
The Divine Market “Free-market... The idea of a ‘divine market' is... by Gaëtan Irrmann
The Pronétariat Revolt - by Joël de... Internet enabled a new kind of... by Rudy Guénaire
The Birth of Biopolitics - Lectures at... In these Lectures at the Collège de... by Marie Calmettes
Natural capitalism: creating the next... At the beginning of the 21st century,... by Claire Nativel