Profit over people - by Noam Chomsky[Reading report] by Julie Vinay

2008-05-02

The author was part of the "Alternative Management" third year program in HEC Paris in 2006/2007

In this book, Chomsky denounces Friedman's definition of democracy, which « gist is to make profit ». Most of the time, formal and election democracy is not really one anymore, because the control of big investors is no public decision. Consequently, debates are mediocre, people are given no choice when voting and votes just reflect market principles, meaning the political financial contributions from the richest individuals and from big firms « investing » in politics. This neoliberal democracy, which he called « hypocrital », and which creates only consumers (vs. citizen) and malls (vs. communities), is « the major enemy of a real participative democracy. »

Quote article  Julie Vinay, « Profit over people - by Noam Chomsky », 02 may 2008, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Reading report]
http://appli6.hec.fr/amo/Articles/Entry/Item/52.sls

In the same section

La Perte des Sens - by Ivan Illich

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Pablo Nomanza

This reading note is an attempt to identify some of the ideas developed in the book -– while trying to depict how coherent and achieved Illich's progression is. Comments emphasise both the content of the book, that is to say Illich's radical criticism of the industrial era and the alternative he...

>>Read more

The mystery of capital: why capitalism triumphs in the West and fails everywhere else - by Hernando de Soto

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Sylvia Marie d'Albertas

Why does capitalism triumph in the West and fail everywhere else? That is the question that Hernando de Soto tries to answer in this book about the mystery of capital. With an analysis of the private property systems in developing countries and countries from de ex-communist bloc, the book shows...

>>Read more

Entrepreneurship after the collapse of the USSR - Study of the first small entrepreneurs in a provincial city of Russia

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Marine Bikard

Through the time of transition, Russian experience is an exceptional laboratory to study the rise of capitalism and its institutionalization. Based on a field study of the first small entrepreneurs, this essay offers a new approach of different ideas developed according to western realities. ...

>>Read more

The Ignorant Schoolmaster – Five lessons in intellectual emancipation.

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Marine Bikard

Through the biography of Joseph Jacotot, a 19th century revolutionary who went into exile, Rancière reminds us the constantly renewed postulate of our political and pedagogical system: intelligences are unevenly distributed and the superior ones should pull upward less smart intelligences....

>>Read more

The Shale Gas Mirage - by Thomas Porcher

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Elsa Walwer

At the heart of the shale gas debate, Thomas Porcher delivers a study about the consequences of French shale gas reserves exploitation, from an economical perspective. Stemming from the French legal and economic specificities, he exposes and dismantles the arguments put forward by pro-shale gas...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Reading report

The Religion of Capital - by Paul... This reading guide reveals how Paul... by Adrien Couret
Dead Aid - Why aid is not working and... During the last fifty years, the total... by Athina Limnatitis
For an ecological pact, Nicolas Hulot... The Ecological Pact was written during... by Loïc Boulenger
Hunger Zero, ending with hunger in the... This book describes the state of hunger... by Hélène Loustau
Immigration: Myths and Realities - by ... Many cons-truths on immigration are... by Guillaume Tellez
The Silent Transformations, by... Western thought, as much as the Greek... by Thomas Desdouits
Crisis of capitalism and death wish -... This book aims at linking two 20th... by Antoine Desjonquères
Slow Food, collected thoughts on taste,... In this book, Carlo Petrini presents... by Audrey Boulkaid
The Right to Useful Unemployment... People have to appeal to a doctor to... by Claire-Isabelle Roquebert
Cannibals with forks - by John Elkington The objective of this review is to... by Dalma Berkovics