The benefits of deliberative democracy – The five estates[Research paper] by Roman Baudin


The author was part of the "Alternative Management" third year program in HEC in 2014. Roman now works as a public sector consultant. He is interested in deliberative democracy issues, State modernization thematics and in the sociology of organizations.

In times of political despair, when representative democracy seems to show its limitations, advocates of deliberative democracy aspire to rebuild democratic legitimacy based on citizens’ deliberation. Relying on the analysis of two famous deliberative events, we show that deliberative democracy can bring strong benefits for collective decision-making, despite the undeniable limits of its practice. We then discuss redesigning the current tri-partition of powers and integrating deliberation in a representative democracy, in order to make politics more… political

Quote article  Roman Baudin, « The benefits of deliberative democracy – The five estates », 30 september 2014, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Research paper]

In the same section

Community currency for local economy : a grassroots innovation for prosperity through democracy?


[Essay] : Christophe Place

Local economy through ruralisation seems to be an alternative to reach a new valuation of prosperity. However, the classical economical and monetary system induces an explosive engine of growth which bring about social inequality and environmental deterioration. Community currencies are innovative...

>>Read more

The Atlas of Migrants in Europe Critical geography of migration policies - by Olivier Clochard

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Marion Coutel

This atlas draws a critical balance from European migration policies and from their human impacts. It explains key concepts and data, such as the European policy of visas, the activities of the Frontex agency, the functioning of the administrative detention centres, dynamics of control...

>>Read more

Hunger Zero, ending with hunger in the world – By Bruno Parmentier

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Hélène Loustau

This book describes the state of hunger in the world, its stakes and its possible solutions. From a holistic perspective, the author sets out the issues to feed humanity at the beginning of the 21st century. While overcrowding and global warming are real issues, hunger is in fact a human creation,...

>>Read more

French higher education towards equal opportunity?

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Nicolas Charles

Whereas social inequalities of access to higher education, in particular to the grandes ecoles, do not diminish anymore, and the need for equal opportunity and justice in higher education becomes more important, numerous higher education institutions, from which the grandes ecoles are very active,...

>>Read more

Creating A World Without Poverty - by Muhammad Yunus

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Camille Portejoie

The challenges of the twenty-first century are significant: climate change, gap widening between the rich and the poor, demographical growth, globalization. Is it possible to solve these problems in our economical and political system? Which institutions, which businesses would be able to face...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Research paper

French higher education towards equal... Whereas social inequalities of access... by Nicolas Charles
Complementary currencies: study of the... Complementary currencies, exchange... by Olivier Torrente
The Rhetoric of Reaction: Perversity,... Whereas the German sociologist Max... by Brice Jeullin
The relationship between the board and... The French associations are currently... by Edouard Tricard
The Resort to Belgium of French people... Facing a major lack of appropriate... by Elsa Walwer
Tourism, business and ethics :... Sustainable tourism is a popular and... by Romain Lhez
The arguments of the debates on German... Codetermination is a form of corporate... by Fabien Hildwein
Education and rural development in... After more than a half-century of a... by Pierre Louis Choquet
Emergence and consolidation of a norm... Palm oil today amounts for 30% of... by Emmanuelle Rica
The Ignorant Schoolmaster – Five... Through the biography of Joseph... by Marine Bikard