The benefits of deliberative democracy – The five estates[Research paper] by Roman Baudin


The author was part of the "Alternative Management" third year program in HEC in 2014. Roman now works as a public sector consultant. He is interested in deliberative democracy issues, State modernization thematics and in the sociology of organizations.

In times of political despair, when representative democracy seems to show its limitations, advocates of deliberative democracy aspire to rebuild democratic legitimacy based on citizens’ deliberation. Relying on the analysis of two famous deliberative events, we show that deliberative democracy can bring strong benefits for collective decision-making, despite the undeniable limits of its practice. We then discuss redesigning the current tri-partition of powers and integrating deliberation in a representative democracy, in order to make politics more… political

Quote article  Roman Baudin, « The benefits of deliberative democracy – The five estates », 30 september 2014, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Research paper]

In the same section

Innovation Support and Public Policy: the Case of the French Medical Biotechnology Industry

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Guillaume Narbonne

Throughout the years, industrial policy in general and innovation support in particular has been accepted as being partly under the aegis of public authorities. It is commonly accepted that innovation plays a key role in fostering growth, and must thus be nurtured and supported. In France, many...

>>Read more

Why don't we all buy organic products?

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Peggy Nicod et Emilie Condemine

Though health and the protection of the environment appear to be the biggest preoccupations in France, only 43% the French population buy organic products. In order to understand this situation, we have studied the consumption habits of consumers and non-consumers of organic products. This study...

>>Read more

Community currency for local economy : a grassroots innovation for prosperity through democracy?


[Essay] : Christophe Place

Local economy through ruralisation seems to be an alternative to reach a new valuation of prosperity. However, the classical economical and monetary system induces an explosive engine of growth which bring about social inequality and environmental deterioration. Community currencies are innovative...

>>Read more

« Participando, articulando, cobrando… » : Understanding the Participatory Budget of Porto Alegre through social trajectories of its participants.

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Luis Emilio Cuenca Botey

This research is a socio ethnographic description of the Participatory Budget in Porto Alegre, Brazil. First, through the ethnographic observation, I describe the deliberative skills of people participating in the Council of the Participatory Budget (CoP), the main deliberation council for the...

>>Read more

Du contre-pouvoir - by Miguel Benasayag, Diego Sztulwark

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Gwenaël Gaigeard

The authors try to pass past former utopian models and former anti-authority idols in order to design the new face of radicality. « Du contre-pouvoir » delivers a realistic and constructive speech about protesting, which contrasts with the approach of other alternative books. From concepts to...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Research paper

Al Amana, critical analysis of a... Al Amana is a Moroc-credit association... by Yazid Arifi
Social housing and energy saving in... As part of the building industry,... by Hélène Doutriaux
Impact of the diverse visions of social... The dynamic of social entrepreneurship... by Camille Portejoie
French foundations and their use of... Social impact measurement is a subject... by Juliette Jaume
The traditional Christian concept of... Antique philosophy is well-known for... by Diane de Zélicourt
Networks of Social Entrepreneurs India This paper aims at deciphering and... by Alban Leveau-Vallier
Perceptions of homeless persons and... The person “on the street” has... by Alix Peillon
The evolution of the Chinese banking... The Chinese banking market is one of... by Jie Zhu
Access to Health Care for African... Facing a new phenomenon of African... by Nastassja Kern
Risk generation: how ans why protest... This thesis considers the Risk... by Pierre-Antoine Chiarelli