The benefits of deliberative democracy – The five estates[Research paper] by Roman Baudin


The author was part of the "Alternative Management" third year program in HEC in 2014. Roman now works as a public sector consultant. He is interested in deliberative democracy issues, State modernization thematics and in the sociology of organizations.

In times of political despair, when representative democracy seems to show its limitations, advocates of deliberative democracy aspire to rebuild democratic legitimacy based on citizens’ deliberation. Relying on the analysis of two famous deliberative events, we show that deliberative democracy can bring strong benefits for collective decision-making, despite the undeniable limits of its practice. We then discuss redesigning the current tri-partition of powers and integrating deliberation in a representative democracy, in order to make politics more… political

Quote article  Roman Baudin, « The benefits of deliberative democracy – The five estates », 30 september 2014, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Research paper]

In the same section

Undocumented immigrants: a fatal archaism, by E. Balibar, M. Chemillier-Gendreau, J. Costa-Lacoux and E. Terray

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Camille Lacroix

Migration policies and mobility control have become key electoral issues. Since 1993 and the Pasqua Laws, conditions of entry and residence in France have been tightened for foreigners: obstacles to the regularization of illegal migrants have multiplied. Confronted with the ongoing and long lasting...

>>Read more

« Participando, articulando, cobrando… » : Understanding the Participatory Budget of Porto Alegre through social trajectories of its participants.

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Luis Emilio Cuenca Botey

This research is a socio ethnographic description of the Participatory Budget in Porto Alegre, Brazil. First, through the ethnographic observation, I describe the deliberative skills of people participating in the Council of the Participatory Budget (CoP), the main deliberation council for the...

>>Read more

Social housing and energy saving in Greater Lyon

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Hélène Doutriaux

As part of the building industry, social housing is affected by the decisions made in the environment and energy fields. The increase in the prices of energy has to be prevented by social landlords to secure their tenants creditworthiness, even if social buildings are generally in better condition...

>>Read more

The economics of functionality, a solution for combating the environmental degradation of the planet? - by Dominique Bourg


[Proceedings] : Dominique Bourg

How to face the environmental challenges which threaten our planet and fight against climate changes produced by our current system of resource exploitation? Dominique Bourg presents the principles of the economics of functionality, a system which, by substituting the leasing of goods for their...

>>Read more

The Right to Useful Unemployment Postface of Tools for Conviviality - by Ivan Illich

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Claire-Isabelle Roquebert

People have to appeal to a doctor to treat themselves, to a teacher to receive a diploma, to an architect to build their houses, to a lawyer to break up with their spouses… That is nothing but the the elite of Professions protecting their privileges. The over-marketisation of society benefits...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Research paper

The protestant ethic and the spirit of... This book studies how the protestant... by Alice de Rochechouart
Is the motivation at work of young... The nature of executives' work has... by Sébastien Stenger.
The Resort to Belgium of French people... Facing a major lack of appropriate... by Elsa Walwer
Adam Smith, l’économiste malgré lui : This master thesis is focusing on the... by François-Xavier Faucounau
Alleviating poverty through profits.... As today's rich get richer, today's... by Lorraine Gérard
The 104 Adventure - Valérie Senghor Graduated in Corporate Law from HEC in... by Valérie Senghor
Which sustainable development for... Confronted with global warming and the... by Claire Nativel
Carbon offset operators in France: How... Very different actors participate in... by Néné Maïga
Career paths of French entrepreneurs ... The concept of fair trade was born from... by Audrey Azilazian
The “Terre de Liens” property... The Foncière Terre de Liens property... by Laura Loffler