The impact of mutualist values on forms of management control A study of three mutualist organizations (MACIF, MAIF, Les Ménages Prévoyants)[Research paper] by Adrien Couret


The author was part of the "Alternative Management" third year program in HEC Paris in 2006/2007.

This study deals with the management of mutual insurance companies (i.e. companies identifiable by collective ownership of their members-clients and by the power of democratic debate in their political decision-making), especially regarding management control. In these organizations claiming to be more generous than others, performance is by nature paradoxical: How do we reconcile the demand for solidarity among members with the pressures of the market economy in such a way that the company remains true to its mutalist roots?

This paradox exposes employess at mutual insurance companies to a strong need for justifying their actions along with those of their company. Basing our theoretical reflexion on "large scale economies" – a French sociology current deriving from conventionalist theories (Boltanski, Thévenot, 1991) – and on social and behavioural approaches to management control (Berry, 1983; Boussard, 2001), we investigated rules of implicit fairness, management processes and the use of key indicators to control performance, in three mutual insurance companies.

Our results display an evident discrepancy between rules of implicit fairness and management processes influenced by a mutualist identity on one side, and the use of key performance indicators that is clearly less specific on the other. This discrepancy is connected to management tools which do not correspond with the mutual company reality: they are still rooted in the determinist economic commercial logic characteristic of the 1980's adaptation to market pressure, while the employees now aspire to read their performance in a way that is balanced by quality indicators.

Quote article  Adrien Couret, « The impact of mutualist values on forms of management control A study of three mutualist organizations (MACIF, MAIF, Les Ménages Prévoyants) », 05 december 2007, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Research paper]

In the same section

Measuring public hospitals' performance in France. Methodological basis, evaluation framework, meanings and perspectives

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Hervé Merlin and Clémence Marty

French public hospitals have recently been dealing with a growing demand for transparency on their results. At the same time, they must adapt to a new regulatory framework that ties future resources to current efficiency, and must give detailed accounts on the fulfilment of their public missions....

>>Read more

Small is beautiful, Economics as if People Mattered - by E.F. Schumacher

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Claudia Pöpperl

This text aims to resume the book “Small is beautiful” by E. F. Schumacher. This book is representing a new economical approach introducing intermediate technology and Buddhist economy.

>>Read more

Patronage in France - by Estelle Lauvergne


[Proceedings] : Estelle Lauvergne

Estelle Lauvergne's career is representative of the evolution of sponsorship in France. She started her career working for a prestigious private company and then decided to enhance her action. She successively had key positions at the Fondation de France and IMS – entreprendre pour la Cité. In...

>>Read more

Getting out of the “Deadly management” - Christian Oyarbide


[Proceedings] : Christian Oyarbide

The multiple activities of Christian Oyarbide crystallize around the thought on management and are as many prisms allowing to tackle managerial issues under different angles. First in professional life, since after leading a private profit insurance company, Christian Oyarbide took the head of a...

>>Read more

The volunteers and the non-profit organization - by Dominique Thierry

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Yoann Kassi-Vivier

The number of volunteers working for associations is growing by 3 to 4% every year. However, non-profit organizations often claim that they face difficulties to attract and retain enough volunteers and skills to meet their growing and very precise needs. If volunteering is not currently in the...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Research paper

"Degrowth": genealogy and circulation... In this paper, we intend to analyze the... by Michaël Bruckert
Industrial ecology, a strategy... The purpose of this dissertation is to... by Elodie Payre
The protestant ethic and the spirit of... This book studies how the protestant... by Alice de Rochechouart
Is car sharing a viable alternative to... The rise of new practices allowing to... by Laure Jaffré
The Movement of Social Entrepreneurs: a... This dissertation aims at analyzing the... by Domitille Harb
Emergence and consolidation of a norm... Palm oil today amounts for 30% of... by Emmanuelle Rica
Perceptions of homeless persons and... The person “on the street” has... by Alix Peillon
Access to Health Care for African... Facing a new phenomenon of African... by Nastassja Kern
Is the motivation at work of young... The nature of executives' work has... by Sébastien Stenger.
Williamsburg, history of a musical... Since the end of the 1980s, the... by Elena Schmitt