Which ethics for moral critics? « Does the end justify the means? » [Article] by Céline Peudenier

2007-12-12

The author was part of the "Alternative Management" third year program in HEC Paris in 2008/2008

In his movie « The Constant Gardener », Fernando Meirelles denounces the scandal of drug trials performed by transnational pharmaceutical companies on uninformed populations in developing countries. Through an exploration of the main characters' ethical dilemmas, he shows how ethics is a subjective and complex notion. But the situation of “Big Pharma” is paradoxically depicted in a simplistic way. It is interesting to reflect on this obvious inconsistency. On the one hand, he explains us how difficult and deceptive it can be to assess the ethic of a particular position. On the other hand, this is exactly what he does with the very unbalanced description of his “target”. Is this the price for effectively raising awareness and triggering (re)-action among the general western public?

Quote article  Céline Peudenier, « Which ethics for moral critics? « Does the end justify the means? » », 12 december 2007, Alternative Management Observatory (AMO), [Article]
http://appli6.hec.fr/amo/Articles/Entry/Item/28.sls

In the same section

The silent takeover: global capitalism and the death of democracy

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Aude Burel

This analysis is a review of Noreena Hertz's book published in 2001, The Silent Takeover. The increasingly smaller margins of politics are the main subject of this essay. Noreena Hertz's core argument is that globalisation, and the growing power of major corporations, is rendering democratic...

>>Read more

The Shock Doctrine: the rise of disaster capitalism - by Naomi Klein

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Guillaume Narbonne

In The Shock Doctrine, Naomi Klein strongly denounces ultraliberalism and its methods of implementation for the past 35 years. By adopting a chronological approach and evoking precise examples, she makes her militant point stronger while shedding light on the logic of the shock doctrine and...

>>Read more

The Divine Market “Free-market cultural revolution” - by Dany R. Dufour

[Reading report]

[Reading report] : Gaëtan Irrmann

The idea of a ‘divine market' is rooted in Jansenist and Calvinist theologies and is symbolized by Adam Smith's « invisible hand ». It states that the satisfaction of self-interest is necessary in order to achieve general interest. By dint of turning human weaknesses into public virtue,...

>>Read more

“Provoking (the right) titles” - by Luis de Miranda

[Research paper]

[Research paper] : Luis de Miranda

The co-director at Max Milo editions as well as a writer, a philosopher and the founder of the organization, “le CREEL”, Luis de Miranda an is actor of his own reality. Provocative but deep-thinking, creative but realistic, he stands up for a more self-critical society. He is the founder of...

>>Read more

Developing a critic conscience for managers - by Philippe de Woot

[Proceedings]

[Proceedings] : Philippe de Woot

Directors and Managers must be aware of the advantages and drawbacks of the capitalist system nowadays. As Philippe de Woot states in his report, this awareness leads to further thought about the implementation of an alternative management that places the humane dimension in the center of the...

>>Read more

With the same doctype

Article

Being an entrepreneur against « the... Whereas our western democracies have... by Kevin Cardona
Alternative entrepreneurship, a... Are all company founders in the... by Florent Gitiaux
Which ethics for moral critics? « Does... In his movie « The Constant Gardener... by Céline Peudenier
Wall Street from Oliver Stone (1987): a... This article tries to address some of... by Mathilde Denoits
The technological society - by Jacques... In The technological society,... by Alexis Lemeillet
The question of power in large... Entrepreneurship is often seen as... by Adrien Couret
The notion of « meaning » at work... Based on a survey conducted in a call... by Hélène Doutriaux, Arnaud Alias, Yahia Bensouda
Art, entreprenariat: the creation's path This article aims to draw up a parallel... by Olivia Conil Lacoste